Image via WikipediaOkay, so I was thinking about the scene in "Exile on Main Street" Episode 6.01, where Sam is trying to prove to Dean that he's not a demon, it kind of felt to me like Sam has gone through this before with him. The whole cutting his arm with the knife and pouring the salt into the water and drinking it to show Dean that there's no demon possessing him. Which lead me to think about the episode "Mystery Spot" the episode where Sam tells Dean over and over again how their stuck in a time loop, how after the 100th time Sam was tired and frustrated; which in a way could be why Sam comes off as cold and harsh in Exile in Main Street.
Here is where my crazy theory factors in "WHAT IF" Sam has told Dean that he's alive but Dean doesn't remember it because 1)there in a time loop or 2) someone or something keeps erasing Dean's memory from him, so whenever he sees Sam it's like it's the first time. Which is very unfortunate for Sam who has to keep trying to get Dean to remember that he has already come to him and told him that he is alive. I mean the theme of this season is "NOTHING IS AS IT SEEMS" so "WHAT IF" this crazy theory of mines is kind of right or maybe just maybe I'm reading way to much into that scene. But a lot of things where off like the fact that Dean didn't yell or even try to make an attempt to hit Sam for keeping the fact that he's been alive from him for a year, and that hug was way off it was nothing like the Sam and Dean hugs we've seen over the seasons. Like I said maybe I'm reading to much into that scene or maybe I'm right. But just in case I am let me post this for all other fans to judge. What if we are dealing with a real Trickster this time?
If you have in theories about this post or about any thing feel free to add on.
